NBC Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
NBC Insider The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon

Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon Try For a Psychic Moment in This Musical Challenge

The Tonight Show Host and the Mufasa composer's go-to karaoke songs popped up in the joyfully chaotic game. 

By Christopher Rudolph
Musical Jinx Challenge with Lin-Manuel Miranda
Video thumbnail
Now Playing
7:10
Highlight
Musical Jinx Challenge with Lin-Manuel Miranda
Video thumbnail
8:28
Highlight
Erin Doherty Talks Shooting Full Adolescence Episodes in One Take and Reacts to the Show's Success
Video thumbnail
5:32
Highlight
Joe List Stand-Up: Watching Movies with Smart People, Becoming a Father
Video thumbnail
6:07
Highlight
Pope Leo XIV Makes History as First American Pope, Trump Calls Pope's Election "Such an Honor"
Video thumbnail
1:16
Highlight
Mr. Grande (Mikey Angelo) Performs a Rap Celebrating All Things Mother (Cold Open)
Video thumbnail
6:10
Highlight
Box of Lies with Shakira
Video thumbnail
4:41
Web Exclusive
Jimmy Interviews a Knicks Fan and Celtics Fan Following the Knicks' Game 2 Comeback Victory
Video thumbnail
8:03
Highlight
Melissa Rivers on Getting Married and Honoring Her Late Mother Joan Rivers with a Special (Extended)
Video thumbnail
9:24
Highlight
Shakira Almost Didn't Release "Hips Don't Lie," Talks About Her Massive World Tour (Extended)
Video thumbnail
7:02
Highlight
Adam Duritz Got a Care Package from Prince After Skipping Out on His Party (Extended)
Video thumbnail
10:17
Highlight
Trump Teases "Earth-Shattering" Announcement, Conclave to Elect New Pope Officially Kicks Off
Video thumbnail
7:52
Highlight
Kerry Washington Confirms She's Involved in the Desperate Housewives Reboot (Extended)
Video thumbnail
7:19
Highlight
Josh Hartnett Invites Fight or Flight Director James Madigan to Join His Interview (Extended)
Video thumbnail
4:05
Highlight
Counting Crows: Spaceman in Tulsa
Video thumbnail
5:14
Highlight
Hey Robot with Nate Bargatze
Video thumbnail
4:23
Highlight
Shakira: Hips Don't Lie ft. Wyclef Jean (Special 20th Anniversary Performance)
Video thumbnail
11:58
Highlight
Lorraine Bracco Opens Up About The Sopranos' Ending, Shares True Story Behind Her Movie Nonnas
Video thumbnail
11:55
Highlight
Nate Bargatze Bought a Watch That Belonged to Darth Vader, Explains Why His Book Has Blank Pages

Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon are both songwriters — have you checked out Fallon's Holiday Seasoning album yet?! — and their love for lyrics was put to the test in The Tonight Show's Musical Jinx Challenge.

How to Watch

Watch The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on NBC weeknights at 11:35/10:35c and next day on Peacock

The two have previously faced off in the Jinx Challenge, but when Miranda visited The Tonight Show on December 2, he and Fallon played a song-filled spin on the glove game.

RELATED: Ring in the Holidays with Jimmy Fallon's Holiday Seasoning Spectacular on NBC!

"We're going to get a song and then on the count of three, we jump out and sing what we think is the most well-known lyric from that song at the same time," Fallon explained to the audience as he and Mufasa composer Miranda both stood onstage, separated by a purple wall. "If we sing the same lyric it's a jinx, which we like."

Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon sing "Wonderwall" and a Christmas carol in unison

Their respective sides of the wall had a screen, which showed the song that they were trying to match. The song choices were playlist staples for Gen Xers and Millennials, so it the task should be easy — but trying to have a psychic moment is trickier than you might think.

The first track was "Wonderwall" by Oasis. After Fallon counted down, the two jumped out to belt what they hoped were the same part of the Brit-rock classic. Back behind the (wonder)wall, they gather themselves, before jumping out and failing again, to sing the same part.

Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon play Musical Jinx Challenge on The Tonight Show Season 12 Episode 37

"It's the chorus! This song's got two parts and we sang 'em," Miranda yelled.

On the third try they finally synced up, both singing the line, "And after all, you're my wonderwaaall..."

Fallon and Miranda may have been knocked down by the first round, but they got up again — ahem — to attempt the next song, which was the '90s one-hit wonder, "Tubthumping" by Chumbawamba.

RELATED: Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon Recreated "Encanto" in a Costumed Song Medley

After singing a song that reminded them of the better times, the next tracks they tried to psychically link on were "I Want It That Way" by Backstreet Boys, "Mr. Brightside" by The Killers ("My go-to karaoke song," Miranda revealed), and the Spice Girls' "Wannabe."

The stakes were raised for the final round, where the two were only given a genre ("Christmas Carols"), and they had to guess which holiday tune the other would sing.

Do their two minds become one? Find out in the Musical Jinx Challenge above.