NBC Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
NBC Insider America's Got Talent: Extreme

Nikki Bella Body-Slammed an AGT: Extreme Contestant—In a Jello Pool

"If you guys wanted a 'yes' from me, this is what you would've done." 

By Christopher Rosa

Nikki Bella is a WWE Superstar, plain and simple. So when a wrestling Act came on the March 7th episode of America's Got Talent: Extreme, they had a lot to prove. 

"I think I already like it," Bella, a new Judge on AGT: Extreme, said about the wrestling Contestants, who called themselves America's Little Sisters. "Love the costumes." 

Indeed, America's Little Sisters did have some fabulous costumes; each of the four women wore metallic outfits in shades of blue, pink, and silver. But unfortunately, their clothes were the highlight of the performance. 

Neither Bella nor her fellow Judges Simon Cowell and Travis Pastrana were particularly impressed that America's Little Sisters were Jello wrestlers. They didn't actually fight each other; instead, they played around in large tubs of Jello, screamed, and defaced a paper cutout of Cowell. They quickly received three X's from the Judges, with Pastrana telling the women, "You came on the wrong show!" 

But it was Bella's feedback that really took the cake—or, well, Jello. "I wouldn't have hit an X if you girls could've done it like me," she said. "In fact..." 

With that, Bella stood up, removed her earrings, and took one of America's Little Sisters to a Jello tub. "If you guys wanted a 'yes' from me, this is what you would've done," Bella said before she body-slammed the Sister into the Jello. It was an iconic moment—made even more iconic when both Pastrana and Host Terry Crews jumped into the Jello, as well. Watch the moment for yourself in the video, above. 

Watch AGT on Peacock and NBC