NBC Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
NBC Insider The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon

Jordan Peele's Halloween Costumes as a Kid Are As Incredible As You'd Think

The director and Scare Tactics EP took a trick-or-treat trip down memory lane with Jimmy Fallon.

By Christopher Rudolph
Jordan Peele Blind Ranks Horror Films and Shares His Childhood Halloween Costumes (Extended)
Video thumbnail
Now Playing
9:19
Highlight
Jordan Peele Blind Ranks Horror Films and Shares His Childhood Halloween Costumes (Extended)
Video thumbnail
6:25
Highlight
Trump and Elon Feud Over Big Beautiful Betrayal, Republicans Regret Passing Spending Bill
Video thumbnail
6:45
Highlight
Annie Murphy and Jimmy Play Mario Kart World on Nintendo Switch 2
Video thumbnail
10:53
Highlight
Benson Boone Flips Off Jimmy's Desk, Talks Moonbeam Ice Cream and American Heart (Extended)
Video thumbnail
0:54
Highlight
Jimmy Does a Backflip for Benson Boone (Cold Open)
Video thumbnail
6:24
Highlight
Annie Murphy Did Kegels with Christine Baranski Between Takes for Nine Perfect Strangers (Extended)
Video thumbnail
3:42
Highlight
Benson Boone: Momma Song
Video thumbnail
11:56
Highlight
Miley Cyrus Got Something Beautiful Advice from Harrison Ford, Teaches Jimmy How to Dance in Heels
Video thumbnail
4:25
Highlight
Turnstile: I Care / Dull
Video thumbnail
9:52
Highlight
Elon Backstabs Trump, Calls His Big Beautiful Bill a "Disgusting Abomination"
Video thumbnail
10:52
Highlight
Owen Cooper Received Praise from Leonardo DiCaprio for Adolescence; Brings Jimmy British Snacks
Video thumbnail
7:46
Highlight
Tyler Perry and Taraji P. Henson Talk Beyoncé's COWBOY CARTER Tour, Met Gala Outfits and Straw
Video thumbnail
6:06
Highlight
Brianne Howey Says Ginny & Georgia Season 3 Is the Most Dramatic Yet
Video thumbnail
13:00
Highlight
Dakota Johnson Prank Calls with Jimmy; Says Pedro Pascal Steals All Her Clothes (Extended)
Video thumbnail
10:05
Highlight
Trump Throws TACO Tantrum, Elon Waves White House Goodbye with a Black Eye
Video thumbnail
5:56
Highlight
Fast Forward with Dakota Johnson
Video thumbnail
4:39
Highlight
Matt Berninger: Bonnet Of Pins
Video thumbnail
8:55
Highlight
Jonathan Groff Shares Photo in "Baby's First Chaps" for Beyoncé's Cowboy Carter Tour

Get Out, Us, and Nope director Jordan Peele is a modern master of horror — and his obsession with all things scary date all the way back to his wildly creative childhood Halloween costumes. 

How to Watch

Watch The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on NBC weeknights at 11:35/10:35c and next day on Peacock

During an October 10 visit to The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, Peele shared some vintage photos of his best trick-or-treating looks.While some children might dress as their favorite superhero or a vampire, Peele's costumes were far more intricate.

The first image Jimmy Fallon showed was of a young Peele dressed as a poker table, complete with cards, and cans of beer. He even had the tablecloth pattern on his face, and a plate of pretzels on top of his head.

Peele also dressed up as a half-angel/half-devil, with one side of him wearing a white angel's robe and halo, while the other side was painted red, wearing devil horns, and holding a pitchfork. 

"When your kid wants to dress like this, you know you have problems on your hands," joked Peele.

RELATED: From Comedic Genius to Horror Master: Retracing Scare Tactics EP Jordan Peele’s Career

Jordan Peele blind-ranks horror films during an interview with host Jimmy Fallon

Another photo featured Peele as Beetlejuice in 1988, when the original movie was released. Unlike Beetlejuice costumes of today, Peele revealed his was homemade: "They didn't have the store-bought Beetlejuice costumes... you had to find stuff in the garbage."

The final image was a more recent pic of Peele, wearing a white t-shirt with a body of a baby on it. Who was he? "Baby Forest Whitaker, a baby with gravitas and menace," Peele said, as he impersonated the Oscar-winning actor.

Jordan Peele ranks classic horror movies on The Tonight Show

Fallon also challenged him to blind rank six horror movies classics including The Exorcist, Psycho, and A Nightmare on Elm Street

RELATED: Prince Harry Giggled After Being Scared at Jimmy Fallon's Tonightmares Maze

Which made the auteur's top slot? Watch his Tonight Show interview to find out.

Jordan Peele is an executive producer of the Scare Tactics reboot

One of Peele's latest projects is the reboot of the hidden camera reality show, Scare Tactics, which premiered Friday, October 4 on USA Network. Peele serves as one of the executive producers on the series.

"Each episode will feature devious pranksters setting up friends and family, known as targets, in hilariously twisted scenarios that blur the lines of reality, horror, and comedy," read the official synopsis. "From a casual dinner party that takes an unexpectedly cannibalistic turn to a pair of newlyweds that are the proud new parents of something ... less than human, the targets will navigate one unreal decision after another as audiences laugh, jump, and are left breathless for more."

Back in June, Peele teased that his next directorial effort will be released on October 23, 2026 — so start planning your costumes now!