NBC Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
NBC Insider The Voice

Why Kevin James Graham's Blind Audition on The Voice Was a "Total Shockaroo"

“You tripped me right up," one Coach said to this Artist. Here's why. 

By James Grebey
Kevin James Graham Shocks Coach Reba with "Stay with Me" | The Voice Blind Auditions | NBC
Video thumbnail
Now Playing
4:15
Highlight
Kevin James Graham Shocks Coach Reba with "Stay with Me" | The Voice Blind Auditions | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:47
Highlight
Blake Shelton Performs "Texas" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:28
Highlight
James Bay and Sheryl Crow Perform "You and Me Time" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:57
Highlight
Chance the Rapper Performs "Space and Time" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:39
Highlight
Kelly Clarkson Performs "Where Have You Been" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:43
Highlight
Jaelen Johnston and Kelsea Ballerini Perform "Whiskey Lullaby" by Brad Paisley | Voice Lives | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:48
Highlight
Adam David and Michael Bublé Perform "The Weight" by The Band | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:14
Highlight
Lucia Flores-Wiseman & Adam Levine Perform "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" | Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:47
Highlight
Bryce Leatherwood Performs "God Made" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:42
Highlight
RENZO and John Legend Perform "As It Was" by Harry Styles | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:54
Highlight
Foreigner Performs a Medley of "I Want to Know What Love Is" and More | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
7:52
Highlight
And the Winner of The Voice Is... | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:01
Highlight
Joe Jonas Performs "Heart By Heart" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:03
Highlight
The Top 11 Perform Bastille's "Pompeii" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:54
Highlight
Jadyn Cree and Michael Bublé Perform "I Got You Babe" by Sonny & Cher | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:10
Sneak Peek
Olympian Mikaela Shiffrin Shocks Bublé and Kelsea with Her Musical Talents | Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
3:37
Highlight
Maelyn Performs "Dreamboat" | The Voice Live Finale | NBC
Video thumbnail
2:59
Highlight
Adam David Performs "Hard Fought Hallelujah" by Brandon Lake & Jelly Roll | Voice Live Finale | NBC

It’s about as pure an example of The Voice’s central premise in action as you’ll see. In Season 26, Episode 4, two Coaches were utterly flummoxed during a Blind Audition because they thought the voice they were hearing would belong to somebody very different — with a different gender — than who was actually up there on stage singing. 

How to Watch

Watch The Voice on NBC and Peacock. 

RELATED: A Full Breakdown of How The Voice Works

The singer, Kevin James Graham, is a 33-year-old from Boston. Not that you would’ve necessarily guessed that from the way he sang Rod Stewart’s “Stay With Me.” 

Kevin James Graham’s Blind Audition on The Voice Season 26

Kevin James Graham sings on stage on The Voice Season 26 Episode 4.

His voice was strong and it was very high, leading to some visible confusion among the Coaches. In the end, Reba McEntire alone pressed her button to turn her chair around, and what she saw surprised her.  

“You look like that!?” McEntire exclaimed. 

“I’m watching her the whole time and she pressed her button,” Gwen Sefani said of her fellow Coach. “And then she saw it wasn’t the girl she was looking for.”

Michael Bublé was also surprised. 

RELATED: Snoop Dogg’s “Seducing” of This 4-Chair Artist Has the Other Coaches Sweating 

“I kept yelling at Gwen ‘is that a minor?’ Either that is a female or a young dude,” he recalled. “You tripped me right up.”

“I swear I thought you were a female. With your high voice, I thought ‘Well, I do need another girl singer.’ I turn around, and there you stand,”  McEntire said to the newest member of her team. “But man, you totally sang your butt off. That was great.”

Snoop Dogg had the opposite problem. 

“This is why I’m mad,” he explained. “I was looking for a male singer, and I didn’t push the button because I thought you was a damn woman! You fooled me, man! And then Reba went and did it.”

“Man, I thought that was a woman, Reba. That’s the only reason why I didn’t push it,” Snoop said as the chairs began to spin back around. McEntire agreed, saying “That was a shockaroo.”