Bryan and David have decided that it's time to find godparents for their baby, hoping to establish some spiritual guidance for their child since they have little themselves. Bryan would love for his child to have some religion in his or her life; he grew up Catholic and attending church, and misses the traditions. Meanwhile, David is Jewish - although more by culture than by belief. But when their first pick for godparents, a highly spiritual lesbian couple, turns them down, Bryan and David are left empty-handed.