The game starts out with five contestants: Charity, Joel, Paul, Sister Rose and Steven. In Round 1, Charity holds on to her hot dog prize, which sends her home, as the lowest-valued prize in the round. Sister Rose winds up with a man cave prize package in Round 2, and this unlikely prize secures her elimination. Energetic college student Joel takes a Mercedes from Paul in Round 3, which sends Paul and Steven to the Prize Fight. Steven is hoping to keep his trip to Peru, a camping gear package and a trip to see the Backstreet Boys, while Paul's prizes include a Waverunner, a dry jet massager and a trip to Miami for 20. Both guys get emotional about their mutual desire to help their families while discussing their decisions. In the end, both guys choose "Keep Mine" - which means both Paul and Steven get to keep their prizes, and an additional $25,000 each!