Sami opens up to Brady about how troubled she is about "Rafe" encouraging Johnny to fight. Brady manages to convince Sami that Johnny just misunderstood. Sami goes with that, until Johnny says Rafe gave him boxing lessons and demonstrates. Sami brings the kids to Caroline, wanting to have it out with Rafe. She's surprised to learn from Caroline that Rafe was at the Brady Pub earlier and was in a hurry to leave when he heard Sami was coming. Sami, her suspicions confirmed, leaves to confront him. The thief tries to steal Melanie's necklace from Carly, but Melanie's on to him. She catches him red-handed and tries to call the police. As they struggle, Brady arrives to help Melanie. Later, at the police station, the thief enters in handcuffs. Meanwhile, Gabi and Will get the security video with the thief on it from the pawn broker. Gabi wants to show it to Rafe because he'll know what to do about "him." Gabi reveals to Will she knows the thief and she's scared. When imposter Rafe arrives at the station, the thief knows him, but "Rafe" has no idea who he is. Suddenly, Gabi shows up and cries out the thief's name, Dario, just as Sami arrives in time to see "Rafe" looking like a deer in the headlights. Melanie and Brady share a close, sweet moment after her encounter with Dario. Lexie questions Taylor about how wise it is for her to be moving in with Nicole and EJ, giving the feelings Taylor has for EJ. Taylors insists it's something she must do for her mother, and her sister – regardless of her feelings for EJ. Meanwhile, EJ insists to Stefano that the real Rafe be moved out from the basement. Stefano doesn't understand until Taylor arrives with her bags and Nicole informs him that Fay and Taylor are moving in. Nicole helps her sister unpack, and Taylor promises she won't get in the way of Nicole and EJ. At the same time, Stefano confirms to EJ that Rafe will be out of the house by tonight. Kate questions why EJ pushed for her to get Allie out of town. EJ covers, but Kate still senses something is up. She learns from Lexie that Taylor is moving in, and is irked by Lexie's opinion of it.