Sami catches imposter Rafe giving Johnny some shocking advice, and it seems like she can no longer accept him for who he is. "Rafe" tells Sami that Johnny needs to know how to fight for protection. Later, Sami questions Johnny, who likes Rafe the way he is, but Sami feels the opposite. At the police station, imposter Rafe looks up an old picture of himself from his criminal days. Daniel realizes Carly stills hurts over Bo. Daniel goes to Bo and chews him out a bit, which Bo takes like a man. Adrienne tells Jennifer that Justin proposed. Jennifer gets upset over Jack. Later, she runs into Daniel. He gets her to play darts, and they have a great time. Nathan tells Maggie about things being over between him and Melanie. Elsewhere, Melanie tells Carly the same. While Melanie seems more at peace than ever, Nathan is feeling more persistent. He stops by to see Melanie, but Carly makes it clear he should not do it again. However, Nathan believes it's not over for them. Will and Gabi confront Kinsey about Gabi's stolen earrings, and Bo has to stop the girls from fighting. Kinsey explains she bought the earrings at the local pawnshop. After Kinsey storms off, Will and Gabi feel the need to do some investigating of their own. Meanwhile, the thief's crime spree continues. Later, Will convinces the pawnbroker to let them see the tape. Gabi gasps, claiming she knows the person on the tape. At the pier, the thief spots Melanie, and the expensive necklace she's wearing...