It's Christmas Eve in Salem. While the traditional ornament hanging gets underway at Alice Horton's, Lexie and Abe search for Theo, who has gone missing. Sadly, this plays into Bo's premonition that something terrible has happened to Theo, but it's Bo, with the help of a ghost from Christmas past, who eventually finds him. The ornaments are hung and despite trying to fit into the festivities, Chloe drops her new ornament and it breaks. Julie and Maggie reassure Chloe it's fine and they will get her a new one. Daniel can't take his mind off of Chloe. Bo can't shake the feeling that something else is going to happen to Theo. Stefano throws a little get together. John brings Marlena and Brady. Both are not thrilled, but John explains Christmas is about family - and he wants to unnerve Stefano. Brady and Nicole argue and she asks John for money. John calls Dr. Taylor, saying he needs to remember his past. Back at the DiMera mansion, Tony realizes he's the odd one out in the new DiMera family. At the end of the night, Chloe sings "Silent Night" at the Horton home while Nicole vows to find an infant of her own.