It's now been two months since the Greendale Seven have been kicked out of school. To stay connected, the group has potluck gatherings, including Troy's Bagel Bites casserole with a Doritos glaze. Abed shows up with an odd dish: a police officer. Looking for evidence proving Dean Pelton has been replaced with an evil twin, Abed was caught going through the administration's dumpster bins. The Dean has offered an ultimatum: either Abed meets with a psychiatrist or the school will press charges for trespassing.