Patriot. Hero. Gun aficionado. John Casey is clearly larger than life--a true warrior always ready to fight for what he believes in, without a shred of doubt. But there's one question that haunts him: did he choose the right path on that fateful day when he was recruited by Colonel Keller? Help us decide by sharing your thoughts on which way it should have gone and why. We got the discussion started with a few arguments for both sides. Machine guns and hot zones or nail guns and hot dogs? You decide.

  • Learning all six ways to kill a man, using only an elbow.
  • Pulling concrete chunks of the Berlin Wall down with his bare hands.
  • Becoming impervious to torture, like sleep deprivation, electric shocks and dental extraction--then learning to actually enjoy it.
  • Laughing while shooting a .50 caliber machine gun from a helicopter, while hovering over a hot zone.
  • Leading black ops missions to Central America to take out communist despots.
  • Being able to check out an Abrams tank from the company motor pool whenever he feels like it.
  • Flying the first stealth bomber through a hostile air space.
  • Sitting on his favorite couch and enjoying a beer and the Super Bowl with the guys.
  • Being there to see his daughter play "Alice" in her school play.
  • Hosting the neighborhood's marquis 4th of July barbeque, highlighted by a pyrotechnic display featuring fireworks of his own creation.
  • Training Gipper, the Golden Retriever, to sniff out the potheads in the neighborhood.
  • Enjoying a long cruise with the wife on their anniversary.
  • Scaring the snot out of every kid who comes to the house to pick up his daughter for a date.

THINK HE GAVE UP TOO MUCH? SOUND OFF BELOW!