Kay is the strong-willed daughter of Sam and Grace Bennett, sister of older brother, Noah, and younger sister, Jessica. As a teenager, Kay stopped at nothing to win the affections of Miguel Lopez-Fitzgerald, but he fell in love with her cousin, Charity. After tricking Miguel into sleeping with her, Kay became pregnant with his baby and gave birth to Maria. Kay was devastated when Miguel left Harmony to chase after Charity. During Miguel’s absence, Kay found love with Fox Crane and ditched her scheming ways. Miguel returned to Harmony (sans Charity) and soon realized he had feelings for Kay, leaving her torn over which man to marry. Kay lives with Tabitha and is privy to the secret that she is a witch.